26-32. The Entire Harry Potter Series, J. K. Rowling

View previous topic View next topic Go down

26-32. The Entire Harry Potter Series, J. K. Rowling

Post  jrpstonecarver on Sat Nov 12, 2011 10:08 pm

The final Harry Potter movie has shipped on DVD and will be here soon, which means it was time to reread the entire series as part of my ongoing interest in how books are changed as they become movies.

As you might expect, the earlier books in this series suffer less change than the later ones, where Rowling had the ability to ship 800 page books without fear. Getting such monsters into a single movie - or even two - is tough.

Overall I think the screen writer did a pretty good job. In many cases entire sub plots are dropped out, and other things are re-ordered and/or simplified to make them work better on the screen. I found the number of times that lines or actions given to one character in the books are given to someone else in the movies amusing, but it makes sense since hard core fans will recognize those kinds of things.

There are a few places in the movies where things are simply not explained. They're pretty subtle, but there. A simple example: the kids take the Hogwarts Express train from London to the school. Clearly that trip takes a few hours, based on how it is described. But when they fly to London on thestrals, the movie glosses over the time required, whereas the books tell you that thestrals fly really fast, apparently much faster than the train. Other small stuff is like that. The movie doesn't explicitly say Draco repaired the vanishing cabinet, nor why it needed repair in the first place, but the books tell you that, and so on.

If I have a beef with these books, it's the King's Cross bit towards the end of Deathly Hallows. Harry desperately wanted to see is godfather again, but that didn't happen. There's some indication that he will meet him again - when he (Harry) dies - but clearly no way to talk to him now. Then, however, we have a long discussion with Dumbledore in Harry's imagined King's Cross station. Why? How? Rowling doesn't explain that well enough for me, nor why Harry didn't meet Sirius, Lupin, and Tonks there too. Others might not have minded, but it bugged me as I read it.

Still, these are fun books. They keep readers of any age interested and wondering what is going to happen. Rowling's world is deep enough and complex enough that it feels real, which is the sign of a good author in my mind.

I'll read these again at some point. Good stuff.
avatar
jrpstonecarver
2011 (31-40) Spock
2011 (31-40) Spock

Posts : 139
Join date : 2008-12-27
Location : Los Gatos, CA

View user profile http://www.bangtherockstogether.com/

Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum